Nate Silver (@NateSilver538): live posts and tweet count

The latest @NateSilver538 posts on X as they land, with today's post count, the last 7 days and the pace against the usual daily rate.

Updated 0s ago · Free board, delayed at least 60 s

Nate Silver @NateSilver538 on X

Nate Silver has posted 0 times so far today, Sunday, November 22 (New York time), against a usual 1 by this hour.

Today
0
Usual by now
1
Last 7 days
54
Daily average
7.7

Below usual

Latest posts

  1. Quote

    I dunno, but plausibly the productivity is multiplicative, not additive. Like, you need both a very smart human and a very smart computer. For *right now* the people who seem to be getting the most use out of LLMs are people who already have a lot of domain expertise etc.

    The Riemann hypothesis has resisted all human mathematician effort but has now been solved by a lab employee working on it as a “hobby” on his spare time with access to internal models and extremely high compute (latter of which we can tell even based on sheer size of this proof…

    Quoting Talia Ringer 🕊🪬Yeah people keep pinning Levent as a non-expert AI bro because he (1) works at an AI company, and (2) posts on this website like a bro. But Levent doing cool t…

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 136 ms

  2. Reply
    1. The complaints that WAR is too influential among the Democratic consultant class is also kind of a weird thing to bring up when Democrats just won 56 Senate seats and 260 House seats.

    2. Like you didn't have many people arguing that the Boston Red Sox were too reliant on analytics after they won the 2004 World Series.

    "You can't Moneyball elections" bro you sound like Skip Bayless.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 213 ms

  3. Reply
    1. The complaints that WAR is too influential among the Democratic consultant class is also kind of a weird thing to bring up when Democrats just won 56 Senate seats and 260 House seats.

    Like you didn't have many people arguing that the Boston Red Sox were too reliant on analytics after they won the 2004 World Series.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 188 ms

  4. Post

    The complaints that WAR is too influential among the Democratic consultant class is also kind of a weird thing to bring up when Democrats just won 56 Senate seats and 260 House seats.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 88 ms

  5. Reply
    1. @NateSilver538 The overriding impulse of election science denialists, like climate science denialists, is to treat the subject as inscrutable and mock the notion that we can conclude anything. They will nitpick individual measures without proposing alternatives.

    2. @NateSilver538 @jonathanchait Sorry, Nate, I don't think you're Isaac Fucking Newton! You're a clever pundit with a calculator.

    3. Dude you're smarter than this, the whole reason to make predictions is to test whether your models of the world are falsifiable. We've been making testable predictions for years and gotten a lot of shit right and beaten markets/pundits/other models/the CW etc.

    And like do you think I've never thought about this stuff I write a whole freaking book that was basically about the history of prediction

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 218 ms

  6. Repost
    Nate Silver reposted

    The other thing is to remember that long before anyone was doing statistics on this, we had these notions. E.g., why did Roy Moore lose to Doug Jones in bright red Alabama? You don't have to be a statistician to say "if the GOP nominates a better candidate they win".

    I mostly try to stay out of the WAR wars re: candidate selection. But to be clear, one side of that debate is almost ... denialist. Yes, candidate strengths exist; they can be measured (imperfectly) and predicted to some degree.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 94 ms

  7. Reply
    1. I mostly try to stay out of the WAR wars re: candidate selection. But to be clear, one side of that debate is almost ... denialist. Yes, candidate strengths exist; they can be measured (imperfectly) and predicted to some degree.

    There's quite a bit of data in Congressional elections vs. presidential ones. Yes, it's confounded in sometimes complicated ways. But there are statistical techniques to grapple with that! If you don't like Split Ticket WAR, build your own model, make some predictions!

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 216 ms

  8. Post

    I mostly try to stay out of the WAR wars re: candidate selection. But to be clear, one side of that debate is almost ... denialist. Yes, candidate strengths exist; they can be measured (imperfectly) and predicted to some degree.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 231 ms

  9. Reply
    1. Idk, if you don't use the models for coding or data-oriented tasks, you might think this. And I don't think super-skilled coding = super-intelligence. But if you do, it's obvious the models are pretty fucking smart and rapidly improving.

      I think AI models have probably reached a permanent plateau. Have seen little improvement in last 9 months. RSI is a more complicated problem than people think: if models have natural limits there is no RSI that can overcome them

    2. Like I'm getting shit done that would once have taken 3 weeks in a day or two. And I'll admit that I have unusually well-tailored needs for AI coding tools. I'm quite happy with the status quo, but when you see this sort of rapid improvement, it's almost a bit disconcerting.

    I'm very happy to place metaphorical bets (or literal ones, DM me Bruno!) against people who think AI progress has stalled out. And in certain ways I'd be pleased if it has! I think this is kind of an uneducated perspective, though.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 171 ms

  10. Reply
    1. Idk, if you don't use the models for coding or data-oriented tasks, you might think this. And I don't think super-skilled coding = super-intelligence. But if you do, it's obvious the models are pretty fucking smart and rapidly improving.

      I think AI models have probably reached a permanent plateau. Have seen little improvement in last 9 months. RSI is a more complicated problem than people think: if models have natural limits there is no RSI that can overcome them

    Like I'm getting shit done that would once have taken 3 weeks in a day or two. And I'll admit that I have unusually well-tailored needs for AI coding tools. I'm quite happy with the status quo, but when you see this sort of rapid improvement, it's almost a bit disconcerting.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 242 ms

  11. Quote

    Idk, if you don't use the models for coding or data-oriented tasks, you might think this. And I don't think super-skilled coding = super-intelligence. But if you do, it's obvious the models are pretty fucking smart and rapidly improving.

    I think AI models have probably reached a permanent plateau. Have seen little improvement in last 9 months. RSI is a more complicated problem than people think: if models have natural limits there is no RSI that can overcome them

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 207 ms

  12. Quote

    Stephen Miller the most obvious "anonymous" source since Jared and Ivanka.

    A White House official tells me that one of Stephen Miller’s first tasks upon becoming chief of staff (with Trump’s direction) was to search for a replacement for national cyber director Sean Cairncross. The official says Cairncross “did not leave, he was fired,” noting that the…

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 117 ms

  13. PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 204 ms

  14. Post

    I was curious: are late Friday afternoons a particularly busy time for air traffic? Actually, kind of yes, but maybe Duffy and Mullin should have said that instead of filibustering.

    Post image

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 417 ms

  15. PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 181 ms

  16. PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 86 ms

  17. Reply
    1. Yes totally. The finding about attendance is based on an extremely elaborate college hoops model (COOPER) that we've spent 500+ hours on over the years. There are all kinds of controls. I don't feel any need to prove anything by using pretentious academic prose.

      actually it's basically fine to use somewhat-causal language for not-very-causal designs 1) the causal designs are massively overrated in their ability to claim right to use causal language 2) most reasonable uses of data don't require you to know causality (if ticket sales pred…

      Quoting John B. HolbeinLots of people dunking on this research design. That’s fair. But I’d like to focus on something else: the language. The language two-step people doing condit…

    The secret behind what we do at Silver Bulletin, and before that at 538, is our work is meant to be accessible to a wide audience. But it's *also* incredibly detail-oriented and rigorous if you look under the hood. We don't want Silver Bulletin to read like an academic journal.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 113 ms

  18. Quote

    Yes totally. The finding about attendance is based on an extremely elaborate college hoops model (COOPER) that we've spent 500+ hours on over the years. There are all kinds of controls. I don't feel any need to prove anything by using pretentious academic prose.

    actually it's basically fine to use somewhat-causal language for not-very-causal designs 1) the causal designs are massively overrated in their ability to claim right to use causal language 2) most reasonable uses of data don't require you to know causality (if ticket sales pred…

    Quoting John B. HolbeinLots of people dunking on this research design. That’s fair. But I’d like to focus on something else: the language. The language two-step people doing condit…

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 205 ms

  19. PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 99 ms

  20. Reply
    1. I think what's noteworthy about Silicon Valley CEOs, not just in AI, is the degree to which they're skating behind the puck. Like it shouldn't have been *that* hard to imagine 2024 being the peak for MAGA rather than a takeoff for it.

      .@galendruke and @NateSilver538 on whether AI CEOs are good at politics.

    2. I'm not going to claim I did a *fantastic* job of that, but I think I did better than Silicon Valley. Like, this article from a week after the 2024 election holds up pretty well, viewing it as analogous to 2004 (somewhat implying the backlash in 2006/08) https://www.natesilver.net/p/its-2004-all-over-again

    But Silicon Valley sees itself as not just "on trend" but ahead of the trend. And it clearly hasn't been that. (Ahead of the trend right now might be thinking about the backlash to Democrats in 2030/32). Instead, it's extremely reactive about politics even more than DC tbh.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 204 ms

  21. Reply
    1. I think what's noteworthy about Silicon Valley CEOs, not just in AI, is the degree to which they're skating behind the puck. Like it shouldn't have been *that* hard to imagine 2024 being the peak for MAGA rather than a takeoff for it.

      .@galendruke and @NateSilver538 on whether AI CEOs are good at politics.

    I'm not going to claim I did a *fantastic* job of that, but I think I did better than Silicon Valley. Like, this article from a week after the 2024 election holds up pretty well, viewing it as analogous to 2004 (somewhat implying the backlash in 2006/08) https://www.natesilver.net/p/its-2004-all-over-again

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 130 ms

  22. PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 142 ms

  23. Quote

    Doesn't make a lot of sense. It's not an easy race. Vance underperformed in his one Senate win and Brown is an overperformer. And we'll see but 2028 could be another blue or blue-ish year.

    Politico: Some Republicans in Ohio are hoping JD Vance runs for Ohio’s Senate in 2028 if he decides not to run for president “JD Vance would be a dream candidate,” said one Ohio Republican. Link to article: https://www.politico.com/news/2026/11/18/senate-map-2028-bernie-moren…

    Post image

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 192 ms

  24. Reply
    1. Cool finding we'll incorporate into our college basketball ratings: crowd size really does matter. Based on data since 1978, a 20,000-person crowd is worth ~1.5 points of additional home-court advantage relative to an empty gym.

    This lines up remarkably well with the decline in home court in the COVID season too, and there are lots of robust controls for team quality and so forth too. So showing up and screaming your lungs out really does help, a bit.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 113 ms

  25. Post

    Cool finding we'll incorporate into our college basketball ratings: crowd size really does matter. Based on data since 1978, a 20,000-person crowd is worth ~1.5 points of additional home-court advantage relative to an empty gym.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 99 ms

  26. Repost
    Nate Silver reposted

    BREAKING: Democrat Mary Peltola defeated Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, NBC News projects, pushing her party’s Senate majority to 56 seats after a stunning wave election. https://nbcnews.to/4iOoUkT

    Post image

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 82 ms

  27. Quote

    The beef is that Sam Haselby is antisemitic.

    no idea what this beef is about but calling someone "downwardly mobile" is such a cartoonishly elitist way to criticize someone. just say you think he's a dirty poor, nate https://x.com/NateSilver538/status/2122509913670701263?a=CEua0bcqNMEZNKHqiuQ&s=20

    Quoting Nate SilverIt's a robust competition, but nobody on this site exudes more downwardly mobile public intellectual energy than you. And you have a very weird thing about Jew…

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 154 ms

  28. PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 184 ms

  29. Repost
    Nate Silver reposted

    Replying to @NateSilver538

    Speaking as a conservative, I'll just say this: Trump could have realized that building ASI is the least conservative, most radical, most destabilizing thing humanity has ever tried to do. He could have acted on that understanding and signed an executive order pausing ASI development. Instead, he simped for Silicon Valley, cozied up to Big Tech, betrayed conservatives, and betrayed the entire human species.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 74 ms

  30. Reply
    1. Medium-confidence prediction: we're about one major AI disruption to the banking system or aviation etc system away from the Overton window shifting very rapidly. Not a high-confidence prediction because I don't think the people in the White House know what they're doing.

    2. This is related btw. In my experience, for coding-related tasks, the models are doing things extremely quickly as compared to even a few months ago. https://x.com/NateSilver538/status/2122504930082669018?a=735wepw_Mz5xuNDwYis&s=20

      The rate of progress for the AI models is just so much clearer for programming-related tasks than for other things. Like even as compared to when we wrapped up work on FLIPR in July/August, the models are notably faster/better. Whereas progress seems kind of mid on other stuff.

    You're welcome to criticize me for extrapolating from writing sports/election models (we started work on a few improvements to our NCAA basketball model today) but I do use these things a lot for relatively complicated work and the progress is accelerating, maybe exponentially.

    PoliticsNate Silver post countCaught in 109 ms

About this tracker

This page follows Nate Silver (@NateSilver538) on X, one of the accounts on TweetStream's live board of posts that move markets, in its Politics group. New posts are listed newest first with their catch speed: the time from the post's own timestamp to TweetStream's first receipt. TweetStream catches X posts in typically 166 ms.

The count includes what shows on the account's main feed: main posts, quote posts, reposts, and replies that continue its own thread. Other replies are left out. Polymarket's weekly post-count rules describe the same kinds of post, but this is not their settlement figure: each market settles on the tracker its rules name. "Today" runs from midnight New York time. "Usual by now" is the average over the previous 7 days, scaled to the share of today that has passed, and the pace label says whether today is above or below it. A post deleted after TweetStream caught it stays in the count. Posts appear here at least 60 seconds after TweetStream receives them.

More in Politics: President Trump, Donald Trump, JD Vance, Marco Rubio, White House Press Office, Speaker Mike Johnson.

Questions

How many times has Nate Silver posted today?
The Today figure at the top counts @NateSilver538's posts on X since midnight New York time, next to the usual count by this hour and the last 7 days. It refreshes every 10 seconds.
How often does Nate Silver post?
The Daily average at the top is @NateSilver538's average posts per day over the 7 days before today, and the bars show each of those days.
Do replies count?
Only the replies that show on the account's main feed: a reply to its own post that continues its thread. Replies to other accounts, and its replies inside someone else's conversation, are left out. Polymarket's weekly tweet-count rules also count replies that show on the main feed, though each market settles on its own tracker's figure.
Which time zone does the count use?
New York time. Today runs from midnight to midnight Eastern. For the accounts with weekly tweet-count markets, the count rounds start at 12:00 PM Eastern on Tuesdays and Fridays.

Get these alerts in your bot or Discord, 3-day free trial

Pick your own accounts and get each post in your bot over WebSocket or in your Discord server without this board's 60-second delay. TweetStream catches X posts in typically 166 ms.